• Philly Inquirer Op-Ed: It`s Not "Wrong" to "Compare Trump to Hitler"

    From Ubiquitous@weberm@polaris.net to alt.tv.pol-incorrect,alt.fan.rush-limbaugh,alt.politics.media,alt.politics.usa,alt.journalism.criticism on Sun Jan 31 04:33:20 2021
    From Newsgroup: alt.politics.media

    Talk about throwing Godwin’s Law out the window. This latest op-ed from the Philadelphia Inquirer goes so far as to compare Donald Trump to Hitler on Holocaust Remembrance Day. National unity is looking more and more like a pipe dream by the day.

    On January 27, retired Inquirer editor David Lee Preston did his part in remembering one of the worst atrocities in humanity by, what else, comparing President Donald Trump to Adolf Hitler. His piece, aptly-titled “Is it wrong to
    compare Trump to Hitler? No,” dives straight to the point that yes, it is now okay to connect a former U.S. president to the Nazi dictator.

    Somehow, I bet this controversial headline won't even garner a second glance by
    the staff who revolted this summer over an article titled "Buildings Matter, Too."

    Preston began:

    Many people find it offensive to use the Holocaust as a
    yardstick for the political excesses of the last four years
    that culminated in the storming of Washington on Jan. 6. They
    believe that to mention Donald Trump and Adolf Hitler in the
    same breath, as Spike Lee did on Sunday in an awards speech,
    disrespects the millions of innocent victims and survivors,
    diminishing the enormity of the Nazis’ crimes.

    As a son of Holocaust survivors and a grandson of four murdered
    Jews, I might be expected to agree. But I do not.

    Preston attempted to compare the two in broad and highly inaccurate terms such as
    the “child migrants in cages, Muslims banned from entering the U.S.” myths. By that logic, President Joe Biden could also be classified as Hitler considering he
    worked for the administration that built these “cages” and recently signed a travel ban from South Africa. Being the son of Holocaust survivors did not excuse
    Preston from leaving out facts.

    His main source of comparison comes mostly from the Capitol Hill attack on January 6. Not only did he claim “Trump figuratively drove busloads of angry Americans to Washington this month and egged them on after they got there,” he also explicitly compared the day to Kristallnacht:

    Now we have seen in our nation’s capital — indeed, in our
    Capitol — how Kristallnacht could have happened; and
    ultimately how men and women could devise what my father,
    George Preston, an engineer who survived Auschwitz and
    Buchenwald, called an “Industry of Death.” Now we have a way
    to understand the rise of a fascist dictator and the blind
    allegiance of murderous minions.

    Are my fellow Americans who breached the barricades and broke
    into the halls of Congress different from the Germans who
    thought they were doing their patriotic duty by burning
    synagogues and shattering Jewish-owned shops in 1938?

    Absolutely, yes, they are different! Once again, the Capitol Hill attack was reprehensible. What it wasn’t was a night of widespread slaughter and destruction
    targeting an oppressed minority. Any comparison of the two is disgusting, especially during a time when we’re supposed to honor the 11 million lives lost
    to the Holocaust, including six million Jewish people.

    Finally, Preston tried to save face by stating that he’s not suggesting “that Trump would have become another Hitler, or that Trumpism is equatable to Nazism.”
    While that would be the bare minimum of courtesy, he immediately undermined it by
    ending with this: “Is it sacrilegious to suggest a link between Hitler and Trump?
    I don’t think so. I’d say it keeps us vigilant for the warning signs.” Basically,
    'I'm not saying Trumpism isn’t Nazism, but Trumpism could be Nazism, so everyone
    can start comparing Trump to Hitler now.'

    The last thing this nation needs is more lying, fearmongering, and division. And
    the last thing this solemn Holocaust Remembrance Day needed was a sideshow of more whiny Trump comparisons to Hitler.

    --
    Mike Godwin
    "By all means cite GL if you think some Nazi comparison is baseless, needlessly inflammatory or hyperbolic."
    4:05 AM - June 24, 2018 http://www.latimes.com/opinion/op-ed/la-oe-godwin-godwins-law-20180624-story.html

    --- Synchronet 3.18a-Linux NewsLink 1.113